×÷ÕߣºÎº³¤Àñ °üÁÕ ºé¹ó×Ó ÄÂС÷
¡¾¹Ø¼ü´Ê¡¿ ÅÁÂÞÎ÷Í¡£»°¢Ã×ÌæÁÖ£»ÇûÌåÐÎʽÕϰ£»ÁÆÐ§£»°²È«ÐÔ
¡¡¡¡¡¾ÕªÒª¡¿ Ä¿µÄ ±È½ÏÅÁÂÞÎ÷Í¡Óë°¢Ã×ÌæÁÖÖÎÁÆÇûÌåÐÎʽÕϰµÄÁÆÐ§¼°°²È«ÐÔ¡£ ·½·¨ ½«66ÀýÇûÌåÐÎʽÕϰ»¼ÕßËæ»ú·ÖΪÑо¿×飨ÅÁÂÞÎ÷Í¡×飩36Àý£¬¶ÔÕÕ×飨°¢Ã×ÌæÁÖ×飩30Àý¡£ÁƳÌ6 w¡£ÓÚÖÎÁÆÇ°¼°ÖÎÁÆ2 w¡¢4 w¡¢6 wÄ©²ÉÓúºÃܶÙÒÖÓôÁ¿±í¡¢ººÃܶٽ¹ÂÇÁ¿±íÆÀ¶¨ÁÙ´²ÁÆÐ§£¬¸±·´Ó¦Á¿±íÆÀ¶¨²»Á¼·´Ó¦¡£ ½á¹û ÖÎÁÆ2 w¡¢4 w¡¢6 wÄ©£¬Á½×麺ÃܶÙÒÖÓôÁ¿±í¡¢ººÃܶٽ¹ÂÇÁ¿±í×Ü·Ö¼°¸÷Òò×ÓÆÀ·ÖÓëÖÎÁÆÇ°±È½Ï¾ùÓÐÏÔÖø»ò¼«ÏÔÖøÐÔϽµ£¨P£¼0.05»ò0.01£©£¬Í¬ÆÚÁ½×é¼ä±È½Ï¾ùÎÞÏÔÖøÐÔ²îÒ죨P¾ù£¾0.05£©¡£Ñо¿×é²»Á¼·´Ó¦·¢ÉúÂʽ϶ÔÕÕ×éµÍ£¬Çҳ̶ÈÇᣬ²îÒìÓÐÏÔÖø»ò¼«ÏÔÖøÐÔ£¨P<0.05»ò0.01£©¡£ ½áÂÛ ÅÁÂÞÎ÷Í¡Óë°¢Ã×ÌæÁÖÖÎÁÆÇûÌåÐÎʽÕϰÁÆÐ§Ï൱£¬µ«ÅÁÂÞÎ÷Í¡µÄ°²È«ÐԽϰ¢Ã×ÌæÁָߣ¬ÒÀ´ÓÐԺá£
¡¡¡¡¡¾¹Ø¼ü´Ê¡¿ ÅÁÂÞÎ÷Í¡£»°¢Ã×ÌæÁÖ£»ÇûÌåÐÎʽÕϰ£»ÁÆÐ§£»°²È«ÐÔ
¡¡¡¡A control study of paroxetive and amitriptyline in the treatment of somatoform disorders
¡¡¡¡¡¾Abstract¡¿ Objective To compare the curative effects and safety of paroxetive and amitriptyline in the treatment of somatoform disorders. Methods 66 patients with somatoform disorder were randomly divided into research(paroxetive, n=36£©and control(amitriptyline, n=30£©groups for 6 weeks. Before treatment and at the ends of the 2nd, 4th and 6th week of treatment, the clinical effects were assessed with the Hamilton Depression Scale(HAMD) and the Hamilton Anxiety Scale(HAMA),and adverse effects with the Treatment Emergent Symptom Scale(TESS), respectively. Results At the ends of the 2nd, 4th and 6th week, compared with pretreatment the total scores of the HAMD or the HAMA and each factor¡¯s score decreased significantly or very for both groups(P<0.05 or 0.01), and in corresponding period there was no significant difference between the 2 groups(all P>0.05). Incidence of the adverse effects was lower and milder in the research than in the control group, differences were significant or very(P<0.05 or 0.01). Conclusion Paroxetive has therapeutic equivalence to amitriptyline, higher safety and better compliance in somatoform disorders.
¡¡¡¡¡¾Keywords¡¿ Paroxetive; amitriptyline; somatoform disorders; curative effect; safety
¡¡¡¡ÇûÌåÐÎʽÕϰÊÇÒ»ÀàÒÔ¸÷ÖÖÇûÌå֢״ΪÁÙ´²±íÏֵľ«ÉñÕϰ£¬»¼Õß³£·´¸´³ÂÊöÇûÌå²»ÊÊ£¬µ«ÇûÌåºÍʵÑéÊÒ¼ì²éδÓÐÏàÓ¦µÄÆ÷ÖÊÐÔ¼²»¼»ù´¡£¬¼Èʹ´æÔÚijЩÇûÌåÒì³£Ò²²»ÄܽâÊÍ»¼ÕßÖ¢×´µÄÐÔÖÊ¡¢ÑÏÖØ³Ì¶ÈµÈ¡£»¼Õß³£°éÓн¹ÂÇÒÖÓôÖ¢×´£¬·´¸´µ½×ÛºÏÒ½Ôº¾ÍÕï£Û1£Ý¡£¼ÈÍù¶àʹÓð¢Ã×ÌæÁÖÖÎÁÆ£¬ÒòÆäËùÖµĿڸɣ¬±ãÃØ£¬ÊÈ˯µÈ²»Á¼·´Ó¦Ó°ÏìÁË»¼ÕßÖÎÁƵÄÒÀ´ÓÐÔ¡£ÓÐÎÄÏ×±¨µÀ£Û2£Ý£¬SSRIs¶ÔÇûÌåÐÎʽÕϰ»¼ÕßÁÆÐ§ÏÔÖø£¬±¾Ñо¿²ÉÓÃÅÁÂÞÎ÷Í¡ÖÎÁÆÇûÌåÐÎʽÕϰ²¢½øÐÐÁ˶ÔÕÕÑо¿£¬ÒÔ̽ÌÖÆäÁÆÐ§¼°°²È«ÐÔ£¬ÏÖ±¨¸æÈçÏ¡£
¡¡¡¡1 ¶ÔÏóÓë·½·¨
¡¡¡¡1.1 ¶ÔÏó ѡȡ2004Äê8Ô¡«2006Äê5ÔÂÔÚÎÒÔºÃÅÕï»òסԺÖÎÁƵÄ66ÀýÇûÌåÐÎʽÕϰ»¼ÕßΪÑо¿¶ÔÏó¡£Èë×é±ê×¼£º£¨1£©·ûºÏ¡¶Öйú¾«ÉñÕϰ·ÖÀàÓëÕï¶Ï±ê×¼¡·µÚ3°æ£¨CCMD3£©ÇûÌåÐÎʽÕϰÕï¶Ï±ê×¼¡££¨2£©ÅųýÇûÌå¼²²¡£¬ÒÖÓôÖ¢£¬Ò©ÎïÀÄÓü°ÈÑÉïÆÚ¸¾Å®¡£½«Èë×鲡ÀýËæ»ú·ÖΪÁ½×飬Ñо¿×é36Àý£¬ÄÐ7Àý£¬Å®29Àý£¬ÄêÁä28 a¡«66 a£¬Æ½¾ù£¨38.1¡À9.5£© a£»²¡³Ì9 mo¡«23 a£¬Æ½¾ù£¨12.5¡À7.3£© a¡£¶ÔÕÕ×é30Àý£¬ÄÐ5Àý£¬Å®25Àý£¬ÄêÁä19 a¡«64 a£¬Æ½¾ù£¨41.2¡À10.6£© a£¬²¡³Ì11 mo¡«27 a£¬Æ½¾ù£¨10.8¡À11.4£© a¡£Á½×éÐÔ±ð¡¢ÄêÁä¡¢²¡³Ì¾t¼ìÑéÎÞÏÔÖøÐÔ²îÒ죨P¾ù£¾0.05£©¡£
¡¡¡¡1.2 ·½·¨
¡¡¡¡1.2.1 ÖÎÁÆ·½·¨ Ñо¿×鏸ÓèÅÁÂÞÎ÷Í¡ÖÎÁÆ£¬Æðʼ¼ÁÁ¿10 mg・d-1£¬ÒÔºó¸ù¾Ý²¡Çéµ÷Õû¼ÁÁ¿£¬×î¸ß¼ÁÁ¿40 mg・d-1¡£¶ÔÕÕ×鏸Óè°¢Ã×ÌæÁÖÖÎÁÆ£¬Æðʼ¼ÁÁ¿25 mg¡«50 mg・d-1£¬ÒÔºó¸ù¾Ý²¡Çéµ÷Õû¼ÁÁ¿ÖÁ50 mg¡«150 mg・d-1¡£ÖÎÁÆÆÚ¼ä£¬½ûÓÃÆäËü¿¹ÒÖÓô¼Á¼°¿¹¾«Éñ²¡Ò©£¬Ê§ÃßÑÏÖØÕß¿ÉÊʵ±ÁªÓñ½¶þµªÜ³×¿ÀàÒ©Îï¡£
¡¡¡¡1.2.2 ÁÆÐ§ÆÀ¶¨ ÓÚÖÎÁÆÇ°¼°ÖÎÁÆ2 w¡¢4 w¡¢6 wÄ©²ÉÓúºÃܶٽ¹ÂÇÁ¿±í£¨HAMA£©¡¢ººÃܶÙÒÖÓôÁ¿±í£¨HAMD£©ÆÀ¶¨ÁÙ´²ÁÆÐ§£¬¸±·´Ó¦Á¿±í£¨TESS£©ÆÀ¶¨²»Á¼·´Ó¦¡£ÒÔHAMD¼õ·ÖÂÊÅж¨ÁÙ´²ÁÆÐ§£¬¼õ·ÖÂÊ¡Ý75%ΪȬÓú£¬¡Ý50%ΪÏÔÖø½ø²½£¬¡Ý25%Ϊ½ø²½£¬<25%ΪÎÞЧ¡£ÖÎÁÆ2 w¡¢4 w¡¢6 wÄ©¸÷¼ì²é1´ÎѪ³£¹æ¡¢Ðĵçͼ¡¢¸Î¹¦ÄÜ¡£
¡¡¡¡1.2.3 ͳ¼Æ·½·¨ ËùÓÐÊý¾ÝÓ¦ÓÃSPSS.10.0ͳ¼ÆÈí¼þ°ü´¦Àí£¬²¢½øÐÐt¼ìÑ飬¦Ö2¼ìÑé¡£